Reviewing Recordings in Criminal Discovery
Last updated November 2026
Body cam and dash cam video, jail calls, 911 audio, and recorded interviews take hours to review, and what isn't there is easy to miss. Here is what to ask for, what to check, and what EqualLaw does with them.
Recordings are some of the strongest discovery a defense attorney gets, and some of the slowest to get through. A single arrest can produce body cam video from several officers, dash cam video, a 911 call, dispatch radio, and an interview recorded at the station. Add the defendant's jail calls and a witness interview, and one case holds hours of audio and video.
This guide covers the recordings a criminal case may hold, what the rules say about getting them, what to check in each one, and what EqualLaw does with them. It is for any criminal defense attorney, in private practice or a public defender office.
Which Recordings Might Your Case Have?
Not every case has all of these, and each may exist whether or not the prosecutor sent it.
- Body cam video. Each officer at the scene may have their own video. Check which officers appear in the rest of the discovery, then check which of their videos you received.
- Dash cam video. Often a separate video of the same stop. It can show the driving and the moments before an officer's own camera starts.
- 911 calls and dispatch radio. The caller's own words, and what the responding officers were told before they arrived.
- Recorded interviews and interrogations. The defendant's statements and witness interviews. Check that each recording covers the whole session, and ask what happened before the recorder started.
- Jail calls. Calls the defendant made from custody, which the prosecution may plan to use. They are often noisy, with cross-talk and a recorded warning at the start.
- Surveillance and phone video. Business cameras, doorbell cameras, and video taken by witnesses on their phones.
What the Rules Say About Recordings
The rules differ by state, so check yours. Three starting points:
- Evidence favorable to the defense. The prosecution must disclose evidence favorable to the defense that is material to guilt or punishment, and that includes recordings. Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963).
- Federal court. On request, the government must give you any relevant written or recorded statement by the defendant that is in its possession, custody, or control. Fed. R. Crim. P. 16(a)(1)(B).
- New York. Automatic discovery includes the defendant's own written or recorded statements, other written or recorded statements related to the subject matter of the case, and all tapes or other electronic recordings, including recordings of 911 calls. The prosecutor has to make a diligent, good faith effort to find out what exists. N.Y. Crim. Proc. Law § 245.20(1)(a), (1)(e), (1)(g), and (2).
Whether a recording exists is a separate question from whether anyone sent it. What the Rules Expect When You Use AI on Discovery covers the duty to investigate under Strickland and Rompilla.
This page is general information, not legal advice.
What to Check in Every Recording
- Does it run the whole way? Compare its length with the report and with the other recordings of the same event. A gap may be a paused recorder, a lost file, or a cut in the export.
- Who is speaking, and who is missing? Count the voices. An officer who speaks but never appears on camera may have their own recording.
- Does the transcript match what you hear? A transcript helps you read. Listen to a line before you quote it, especially on a noisy call.
- Do the times line up? Check each recording's time against the others and against the reports. A transcript's times can drift from the file's own clock.
- Do you have the original? Keep each file exactly as the prosecutor produced it, and work from copies.
What EqualLaw Does With Recordings
Recordings come in with the rest of the case's discovery: pulled from the prosecutor's portal or email, or uploaded in your browser.
Transcripts That Name the Speakers
EqualLaw transcribes body cam and interview video, jail calls, 911 audio, and other recordings. When something said on a recording shows who is talking, EqualLaw matches the voice to a person identified in the case's reports and other files. Sirens, radio traffic, and other sounds that matter are marked, overlapping speech is kept, and anything it can't make out is marked inaudible, not guessed. You can change who a speaker is and correct any line, and EqualLaw keeps its first wording beside your change.
Timed to the Recording
Click a line's time to jump to that moment, and listen before you rely on the words. EqualLaw also marks key moments that you can jump to and edit.
A Second Reading of Every Transcript
A second, independent recognizer listens to the same audio. Where it and the transcript disagree, EqualLaw marks the line so you know to listen. Where the file itself has no sound for a stretch, the transcript says so and nothing more.
Search Across Everything
Search a name or a phrase, and EqualLaw checks the transcripts, the text of documents and scanned pages, and its descriptions of photos and video. Click a match to jump to that moment in the recording.
Flags for Recordings That May Be Missing
An officer seen or named at the scene is enough for EqualLaw to flag that officer's body cam video, even where nothing mentions a camera. A report that mentions a dash cam, or a recording that mentions a 911 call, gets a flag too. Each flag says why and links to the moment behind it, when there is one. EqualLaw says a recording may exist, never that it does, and you decide whether to ask for it.
A Record of What You've Watched
The review tracker shows how much of each recording you've watched. Fast playback counts as skimming, not watching, and parts you skip don't count. If you reviewed a recording somewhere else, you can mark it reviewed yourself.
“Very nice that the product can analyze for expected discovery like the other officer's body camera footage.”
EqualLaw takes common phone, body cam, and recorder formats, and some DVR exports, including large recordings. An interrupted upload picks up where it stopped. EqualLaw keeps each original as it was, and you can download it. If it can't read a file yet, it says so on the file, and we can add support for that format.
Where You Take Over
- EqualLaw describes video from sampled pictures, not every frame. Watch the video for anything that matters.
- Transcripts make mistakes, in the words and in who said them, especially on bad audio. Their times are estimates. Listen before you quote a line.
- A flag is a lead to check, not proof that a recording exists, was kept, or was required. You decide what to ask for, and whether anything was withheld.
Questions About Recordings in Discovery
Short answers. Bring the rest to a walkthrough.
Look for four things: transcripts timed to the recording, search that covers recordings along with documents, a click that jumps to the exact moment, and flags for recordings that may be missing. EqualLaw does all four. Transcript lines carry a time you can click, and a search match opens the recording at that moment. Choosing Discovery Software sorts the kinds of tools sold as discovery software and gives tests to run on your worst audio.
Start from what the discovery already shows. Body cam video from each officer at the scene, dash cam video, the 911 call and dispatch radio, recorded interviews and interrogations, jail calls, and surveillance video may all exist. The rules depend on your state (see above). EqualLaw flags recordings that the reports and other recordings point to, so you know what to ask for.
List who the reports and recordings place at the scene, then check that you have video from each of those officers. EqualLaw makes that comparison for you. An officer seen or named at the scene is enough for it to flag that officer's body cam video. It says the video may exist, and that it isn't known whether a camera was on. Whether one was required is a question for your case.
It can give you a working transcript, but no transcript is exact on poor audio. EqualLaw marks what it can't make out as inaudible. It checks each transcript against a second reading and marks the lines where they disagree, and it times the lines so you can listen to the moment. Listen before you quote a line in court.
Yes. Click a line's time and the recording jumps to that moment. The times are estimates, so listen to the few seconds around it.
Yes, when the recording shows who is talking, such as when someone introduces themselves, another speaker uses their name, or they give a badge number or callsign. EqualLaw matches the voice to a person identified in your case's reports and other files and puts their name in the transcript. If it can't place a voice with confidence, it keeps a number, such as Speaker 2. You can change who a speaker is and correct any line, and EqualLaw keeps its first wording beside your change.
Common phone, body cam, and recorder formats, and some DVR exports. EqualLaw recognizes a file by its contents, not its name. If it can't read a file yet, it keeps the original as uploaded and marks it. We can add support for that format. Large recordings are fine, and an interrupted upload picks up where it stopped.
Both. It transcribes the audio and describes what the picture shows from sampled frames. Search and the case brief use those descriptions for the video. They are observations, not a record of every frame, so watch the video for anything that matters.
Your case data is never used to train AI models. Security explains where a client's discovery goes and who can see it.
No. The recording is the evidence, and the transcript helps you find and review it. EqualLaw keeps the original file as produced, and you can download it.
Bring a Case With Hours of Recordings
On the walkthrough, we'll look at the recordings your cases hold. The next step is a pilot on one of your cases.